Hard times call for gleaning (new study)

by

The French have a long, proud history (protected by law and immortalized in film) of preventing produce waste by opening up their farms after harvest to allow scavengers  to collect the left overs.  Gleaning still takes place in the countryside, but works a little differently in modern cities, where it takes the form of collecting discarded fruits and veg after farmers markets and from commercial trash bins.

And in these tough economic times, gleaning or “doing the end of the market” is more common than ever in Paris and smaller cities, especially among youth, the homeless and…the elderly.

OFRTP-FRANCE-PAUVRETE-GLANAGE-20090203

Reuters/Eric Gaillard

To get a better sense of who gleans, how and why, the French High Commissioner for Active Solidarity Against Poverty commissioned a report on the topic from a French think tank called The Center for Study and Research on Philanthropy (CerPhi).  So, CerPhi conducted a qualitative study, scoping out prime gleaning spots in Paris and two smaller cities and conducting in-depth interviews with over forty men and women spotted in the act.

While they didn’t exclude people who consider gleaning a political or environmental act, the report focuses on those who glean out of financial necessity.  In other words, everybody but the freegans.

The most interesting take-away is the fuller profile of urban gleaners the study provides. For the most part, they are young people, retirees and the homeless.  Young people have the fewest health and safety concerns about eating discarded produce.  Longtime homeless men use gleaning as a survival mechanism and continue to do it even when they have housing.  Retirees glean out of financial necessity and are, for the most part ashamed of gleaning (with the exception of a small minority who barter what they glean and gain self-worth from the practice).

The study specifically investigated the relationship between gleaners and social security to better inform government  programs.  What they found reveals a lot about pride and the challenges of aging in a failing economy.  Take these two quotes, for example:

Woman, 82 years old, Paris

Have you been “doing market ends”  for a long time?

It’s not really market ends, I buy, I see if I see something.

I think I saw you last Saturday.

Yes, Saturday I was here.  If I see something, I pick it up but I buy a lot.  Really, I do, I buy a lot, and I do it if I find something, otherwise I mainly buy,

Did you buy everything in that bag?

No, I didn’t buy everything, but I bought a good part of it, a large part of this here was picked up, it depends on the day.

Woman, 75 years old, Paris

Are you familiar with food aid, like soup kitchens?

No, I don’t go there.

Why not?

Because my grandchildren work and that doesn’t interest me.

If you read French, the full report is a heartbreaking page-turner full of nuanced questions about what gleaning means to different groups, concepts of transiance and urgency as well as larger societal questions about the relationship between hunger, public assistance and stigma.

And it’s getting harder and harder to be a gleaner, the study reports, as farmers markets and supermarkets go to greater lengths to destroy food waste and discourage scavenging.  Sadly, the report lacks clear-cut recomendations.  I’d love to hear your thoughts on the topic.

PS Thanks, Gillian, for sending me an article on this study in the first place.

Tags: , ,

7 Responses to “Hard times call for gleaning (new study)”

  1. dumpstertaoist Says:

    This article just hurts. Makes me upset. I’m a gleaner of sorts too, even though I don’t really take food anymore. I did in college.

    I don’t think that intentionally destroying perfectly good food and other things meant for the trash makes any sense. I understand what businesses want to do, which is make it impossible to get these things for free so they’ll go into the FRONT of the store instead of around back, but it just doesn’t really make sense in practice, because:

    The people like me taking food and other items from the trash just wouldn’t have bought these things anyway.

    Nothing I find I would have bought. And people looking for food likely can’t afford it or just won’t buy it for various reasons.

    So in my opinion, it’s just greed that makes people destroy perfectly good things.

    😦
    dt

  2. Leila Darabi Says:

    I hear you. Since part of the report is on observing gleaners, the focus is not on people who ruin trash—they cite news reports of supermarkets dumping chlorine on food waste—but rather on the relationship between people who control food waste supplies and gleaners. They observe harsh and kind relationships: people who wait for the trash trucks to come to put out their trash and people who put it out early and don’t mind people going through it. The authors discuss the sense of urgency and competition last minute dumps create. It’s an interesting and cruel power dynamic I had never before considered.

  3. dumpstertaoist Says:

    Doh, was referencing your post. Should have read the whole article before mouthing off. Will do, sorry. Wonder if there’s any mention of the Agnes Varda film in it? I met her, she’s mean 😦 hehe.

  4. Leila Darabi Says:

    Mean? Really? She seems eccentric in the film, to say the least!

  5. esther Says:

    yes, I see lots of gleaners every day, here in Paris… I know lots of friends that do it too…out of financial needs…but even when they do have the moneuy sometimes, it becomes a habit, and why not…it’s a shame, all that waste!!!

  6. Leila Darabi Says:

    Do your friends glean from green markets or the trash bins outside supermarkets, or both? I thought this report was very interesting in addressing the difference in levels of stigma.

  7. The Beaches of Agnès « everydaytrash Says:

    […] since this post is only tangentially trash-related, I’m throwing in this link from a few months back on urban gleaning.  Check it out now if you missed it […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: